Repair of a 1908 Montgomery Ward Keystone parlor guitar. Actually these were considered ŇstandardÓ sized at this time in historyÉ

 

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:ae00-6714_9_ copy.jpg

Side crack shows that this is not Brazilian rosewood laminate but solid birch with a really good faux finish- it convinced the experts at Guitar EmporiumÉ

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9517.JPG

Even birch can crack when it is 112 years old. The finish will get some touchup but I will not refinish it as that will take away its character. Sort of like erasing wrinkles.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9519.JPG

 

These old tuners have seen their better days, they are seized and the knobs are missing. Can't turn several of these even with pliers...

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9555.JPG

Crack one of two in the soundboard from the inside perspective. That will never close no matter how much I humidify it, but several days of intense humidification inside and out will close the gap some before repairing and cleating.

 

 

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9559.JPG

After working a probe and palette knife into the lower bout crack, I was able to realign the bad crack and clamp it before using CA glue incrementally to reattach the sides of the crack. Much better than I expected!

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9561.JPG

Final crack alignment- I worked around it about half an inch at a time hitting it with CA and accelerator at points, then will use capillary action of the thin viscosity glue to solidify the crack. I do not think I will even need to cleat this, though I was prepared to with birch popsicle sticks make into cleats.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9564.JPG

The finished glue job, now I will touch up the finish a bit as well.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9567.JPG

Filled with gap filling CA and a razor scraping to level everything before polishing- which will take  me through 4 levels of polishing. This is the most time intensive part of the repair.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9570.JPG

The binding was missing from about an inch and this will take some realigning as well. I will polish out the bad finish but not disrupt it much.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9574.JPG

Removing the tuners. These will be replaced with a period vintage set I was able to acquire online as these were seized to the point of no return. Any attempted fix would probably leave them unable to tune properly.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9576.JPG

Even after degunking them they would not turn with pliers.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9577.JPG

Re-gluing the binding in a couple of places. You can see the crack in the lower bout in this picture as well. Also the center purfling strip was coming loose and had shrunken.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9581.JPG

This is what 112 year old Adirondack (red) spruce looks like, as best as I can show it. The grain is so tight it almost blends together. The brazing is also from the northeaster forests before they were depleted building airplanes for WW2.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9583.JPG

The two cracks in the soundboard after about a week of humidification closed up considerably. I had considered filling it with a long thin strip of spruce, but will go with a mixture of spruce dust and glue.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9585.JPG

After touching up some of the dings and scrapes in the finish it is looking pretty good. I do this with fine tip permanent markers, furniture touch up pens and even a super fine brush and artistŐs gouache. ItŐs tedious but it words and does not disturb the original finish much.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9601.JPG

The side lower bout crack is looking pretty good at this stage after re-polishing multiple times.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9653.JPG

Preparing to glue the cracks. A band clamp usually will pull any crack together but this one is stubborn. I have used several luthierŐs magnets to cleat this from the inside with 6 inch long half inch wide cleats. This will never open along theses cracks again. I normally use smaller cleats on closed cracks.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9655.JPG

Clamps, clamps, magnets, and more clamps. I use leather to protect the surface and wax paper under the blocks required to keep the soundboard level during gluing.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9657.JPG

This crack is almost closed at this point.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9658.JPG

Forcing the glue into the joint with a suction cup, an old Frank Ford technique. It works as I got squeeze out inside which I clean with a damp towel.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9660.JPG

I work along the crack and will come back later to hit the spots covered by the magnets and clamps.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9662.JPG

Leveling and gluing and cleating the cracks in the soundhole; I used small spruce cleats here- these have grain that runs perpendicular to the crack so it will not be able to expand again. Lool at that Brazilian rosewood in the fretboard- along with the bridge, that is the only Brazilian on this puppy as the back and sides are birch.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9663.JPG

Filling the remaining crack with spruce dust and glue compound. I will shave this after dring and apply color and finish just along the crack itself.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9667.JPG

After filling, before touchup.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9697.JPG

Magnets to hold the cleats while drying. These are extremely powerful rare earth magnets.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9706.JPG

A view of the long spruce cleat.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9729.JPG

Note that the grain runs perpendicular to the soundboard grain.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9734.JPG

Working on the center purfling that a gap appear- apparently because it had had shrunken.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9736.JPG

I used aliphatic resin glue rather then hide glue on this repair.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9737.JPG

Using cherry cauls to keep the surface flat while clamping and gluing.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9738.JPG

Wax paper just in case of squeeze out- this will make for easy cleanup.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9739.JPG

I have an assortment of hardwood cauls for every occasion.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9745.JPG

Filling a gap in the rosette with a sliver of spruce then shaving it off..

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9748.JPG

Re-scraping the filled cracks with a razor blade scraper.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9752.JPG

The lower bout back crack closed before buffing and polishing

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9753.JPG

The period tuners that replaced the originals. These are twinsies of the originals,  probably made by Waverly.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9755.JPG

Touch up and colorizing the fills.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9757.JPG

A bit here a dab and a smudge- this is an ad hoc process and works well.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9759.JPG

 

Waxing sometimes helps...

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9760.JPG

Initial buffing with coarse compound, will work through medium and fine then use Preservation polish to finish it off.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9764.JPG

 

Simichrome polish takes down the finish a bit...

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9765.JPG

 

Buffing with Preservation (non silicone) polish multiple times...

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9767.JPG

 

Lower bout crack refilled again- this is an incrementalfilling process, a little at a time, rescrape, buff, etc..

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9781.JPG

I have a bit more colorizing to do but wanted to show the progress at this stage. I used extra light Elixir strings and it sounds great.

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:IMG_9783.JPG

The action is still way high so the next phase will be a neck reset. I am very pleased with how it turned out cosmetically

Description: Macintosh HD:Users:admin:Desktop:Keystone_photooo:s-l1600.jpg

Original ad for the Keystone in the 1908-9 edition of the Montgomery Ward catalog. Several companies were building guitars for the company, mostly Lyon & Healy at this time. Ths model was gone from the catalog by the 1912 edition, replaced by a solid mahogany version based on the same design.